Send an Assignment

Equipment Breakdown
Investigation

Uncovering the Causes of Malfunctions:
Providing Insights for Preventing Recurrence

Forensic engineers documenting arc flash damage to switchgear, with the equipment locked out

Forensic engineering · Equipment breakdown

Equipment Breakdown Root Cause Analysis: Evidence for Claims and Disputes

Electrical, mechanical and materials specialists, investigating equipment breakdowns across Canada.

When industrial machinery, commercial equipment or a critical building system breaks down, the questions that follow are about cause and liability: what failed, why, and who is responsible. Mission Critical Forensics provides expert engineering analysis to determine the precise origin and cause of complex equipment failures for clients across Canada. Headquartered in the heart of Toronto, our evidence-based investigations deliver the insight needed to resolve insurance claims, support legal proceedings and prevent costly future incidents.

Equipment breakdown (EB) claims are our daily work, from transformers, switchgear and motors to boilers, chillers, compressors, production lines and control systems. We know how equipment fails, what the evidence of each failure looks like, and how to tell a sudden, accidental breakdown from wear, corrosion, a manufacturing defect or poor maintenance: the distinction most equipment breakdown claims turn on.

Request a Consultation with an Engineer Send an Assignment

  • 01

    Multidisciplinary specialists

    Electrical, mechanical, controls and materials

  • 02

    Systemic

    The whole system, not one component

  • 03

    Cause, not just condition

    A sudden breakdown told apart from wear and defect

  • 04

    Independent and defensible

    Evidence-based findings and expert testimony

  • 05

    Cause, traced to its source

    The evidence subrogation and disputes depend on

The challenge

Why Equipment Breakdowns Need a Forensic Engineer

A breakdown often destroys the part that failed first, and the damage spreads to everything around it. Reading what remains takes engineers who know how each kind of equipment works and how it fails, and that is what we are.

01

The first failure hides in the damage

When equipment breaks down, the part that failed first is often destroyed by everything that followed: a seized bearing wrecks a shaft, a winding fault burns out a motor, a failed tube floods a boiler. Telling the initiating failure apart from the consequential damage is where experience decides the answer.

02

Breakdown, wear, defect or maintenance?

A sudden breakdown, gradual wear, corrosion, a manufacturing or design defect, improper installation, poor maintenance and operating error can leave similar evidence. Each has very different consequences for coverage, warranty and liability, and each has to be ruled in or out with evidence.

03

Electrical, mechanical and controls, together

Modern equipment is electrical, mechanical and digital at once. A motor can fail because of its power supply, a pump because of its controls, a chiller because of a sensor. Finding the true cause takes engineers who understand the whole system, not one discipline.

04

The records tell the story, to those who can read them

Control and alarm logs, PLC and building automation data, maintenance and inspection records, OEM manuals and service bulletins, operating history and the accounts of operators and service technicians each hold part of the answer. Interpreting them together with the physical evidence establishes the sequence of events.

05

Every party has its own version

Manufacturers, installers, contractors, service providers, owners and operators each see the breakdown from their side, and each may carry liability. The answer has to come from an engineer who answers to the evidence alone, and it has to hold up when insurers, counsel and courts test it.

Capability

Investigating Breakdowns Across Industrial, Commercial and Consumer Equipment

All complex loss investigations are led by our group of experienced forensic experts.

Electrical Power Systems

  • Low-, medium- and high-voltage systems
  • Power supply and distribution equipment
  • Transformers
  • Switchgear and circuit breakers
  • Utility power surges and distribution faults
  • Electrically induced arcing, fires and explosions

Electrical Equipment & Energy Systems

  • Lightning strike and surge damage
  • Battery energy storage systems (BESS)
  • Solar and wind energy systems
  • EV and EV charging equipment
  • Lighting systems (HID, neon, LED, fluorescent)

Mechanical & HVAC Systems

  • General mechanical systems
  • Boilers, chillers and cooling towers
  • Furnaces, heaters and air conditioners
  • Pumps and air handling units (AHUs)
  • Motors, engines, turbines and compressors
  • Hydraulic and pneumatic systems

Control & IT Systems

  • Electrical control systems
  • Programmable logic controllers (PLC)
  • Building automation systems (BAS)
  • Instrumentation
  • Software anomalies
  • Vehicle electronic systems
  • IT equipment

Commercial, Building & Residential Systems

  • Commercial equipment
  • Elevators and escalators
  • Automated doors
  • Commercial and residential appliances
  • Cooking, heating and laundry appliances
  • Clothes dryers
  • Sump pumps

Fire Protection & Alarm Systems

  • Sprinkler and standpipe systems
  • Fixed suppression systems
  • Aircraft hangar fire protection
  • Fire pumps
  • Alarm and detection systems
  • Smoke management systems
  • Fireproofing and firestop systems

Vehicles & Mobile Equipment

  • Agricultural equipment
  • Construction, mining and forestry equipment
  • Highway tractors and trailers
  • Passenger vehicles
  • Rail systems

Plumbing & Water Systems

  • Pipe breaks and leaks
  • Water losses
  • Piping and pipelines
  • Circulation relief drain piping
  • Water supplies for fire protection

Industrial & Process Equipment

  • Production lines
  • CNC machines and presses
  • Process equipment and systems
  • Process failures and contamination
  • Food processing and fermentation equipment

Materials & Components

  • Metallurgical failure analysis
  • Polymers and plastics
  • Chemical degradation
  • Corrosion
  • Material science and physics-based investigations
  • Structural and general component failures

Chemical & Fuel-Related Incidents

  • Chemical compounds and materials
  • Equipment involved in chemical reactions
  • Combustible dusts
  • Reactive chemicals
  • Thermal runaway
  • Gas leaks and fuel-related incidents
  • Diesel fuel systems

Other Specialized Equipment

  • Scientific and medical equipment
  • Tools
  • Bicycles and wheelchairs
  • Fitness equipment

Often investigated for personal injury claims.

Why Choose MCF for Your Equipment Breakdown Investigation?

When you require an unbiased, expert opinion, the qualifications of your engineering partner matter.

Getting to the Bottom of It

An investigation that ends with the cause “undetermined” leaves the claim unresolved. Our technical expertise and holistic approach, which examines the whole system around the breakdown rather than the one component that failed, take each investigation to the bottom of the issue: a definitive root cause.

Tracing the Cause to Its Source

An equipment breakdown is rarely one party’s problem: manufacturers, installers, contractors, service providers and operators can all be involved. Determining the true root cause, and tracing it to the product, work or operation it came from, gives insurers and counsel the independent technical foundation that loss recovery and subrogation claims depend on. It is what we do best.

Objectivity & Impartiality

As an independent engineering firm, our only objective is to find the scientific truth. Our findings are unbiased and based solely on evidence, making them credible for insurance claims and legal proceedings.

Multidisciplinary Expertise

Our team possesses a deep understanding of electrical, mechanical, chemical and materials engineering principles as they apply to equipment and the ways it fails.

Defensible Reporting

Our reports are written to be clear, concise, and defensible. They are structured to withstand the scrutiny of technical and non-technical stakeholders alike.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an equipment breakdown investigation?

It is the forensic engineering work that establishes why a piece of equipment failed, and proves it. A forensic engineer determines what failed first, the sequence of events, whether the cause was a sudden breakdown, wear, corrosion, a defect, the installation, the maintenance or the way it was operated and what it traces to, with findings that hold up for an insurer, a lawyer or a court. Mission Critical Forensics investigates breakdowns of electrical, mechanical, HVAC, control, building, industrial process and fire protection equipment, and of vehicles and mobile equipment, across Canada.

Who investigates an equipment breakdown claim?

A forensic engineer whose expertise matches the equipment: electrical, mechanical, controls or materials. Mission Critical Forensics (MCF) investigates equipment breakdown (EB) claims across Canada for insurers, adjusters and counsel, from transformers, switchgear and motors to boilers, chillers, compressors and production lines.

Was it a breakdown, or wear and tear?

It is often the question an equipment breakdown claim turns on. A sudden, accidental failure, gradual deterioration, a manufacturing defect and a maintenance or operating failure can look alike once the equipment has failed. Telling them apart takes engineering evidence: the physical failure itself, read together with the equipment’s operating and maintenance history.

Is it a warranty matter or an equipment breakdown claim?

For new or recently serviced equipment, the answer depends on why it failed: a manufacturing or installation defect points one way, an external cause or an operating event another. Establishing the root cause is what answers it, and it often decides who pays.

When should we call a forensic engineer?

As soon as the breakdown happens, and before the equipment is repaired, replaced, scrapped or returned to the manufacturer. Evidence lost in the first days cannot be recovered, and it often decides the claim.

Can you assist with our insurance claim or legal dispute?

Yes. We are frequently retained to provide impartial, third-party engineering analysis for insurance claims, warranty claims, subrogation and litigation. Our engineers can serve as expert witnesses when required.

Which equipment do you investigate?

Electrical power and distribution equipment; motors, engines, turbines and compressors; HVAC and building systems, including boilers, chillers, cooling towers, elevators and escalators; control systems, PLCs and building automation; industrial and process equipment; fire protection systems; plumbing and water systems; appliances; vehicles and mobile equipment; and the materials and components inside them.

Who do you work for?

Insurers and adjusters, subrogation and defence counsel, utilities, and the owners and operators of industrial, commercial and data centre facilities.

Next step

Get Definitive Answers for Your Equipment Breakdown

Make your next decision an informed one. Partner with MCF to understand the true cause of your equipment breakdown and prevent it from happening again. Contact our engineering team to discuss your case.

Contact our engineering team

Got a claim? Need a quick check on subrogation potential?

To get clear, precise and timely insight of your claims

Send an Assignment